ORDERING IS OPEN!!!

ORDERING IS OPEN!!!

Thanksgiving is our favorite (and busiest!) week of the year—each season we bake over 600 pies to share with your families!

To make sure everyone gets just what they need, we’ve put together a few simple guidelines. Take a look below for all the details, along with our full holiday menu!

Thanksgiving Menu

Here it is—the much-anticipated Thanksgiving menu!

Our Thanksgiving orders are officially open!!

Browse the photos, read the delicious descriptions, and place your orders early to secure your favorite pies!

Thanksgiving Menu

What about your other pies??

Fear not—our other pies are still available! They can be picked up the week before Thanksgiving (Nov. 21st) and come frozen with easy thawing instructions.

To order, click the link below, and be sure to select “YES - this is for the holiday” so we can prep accordingly. Whipped cream pies will come without topping to keep them fresh, but we’ll send you simple instructions to make your ow at home!

Daily Menu Pies

 FAQs

  • Yes — if you’re ordering from both our Thanksgiving Menu and our Daily Menu.
    Each menu has a different pick-up day (Nov 21 for frozen daily pies, Nov 26 for fresh Thanksgiving pies), so you’ll need to click both ordering links on our website and check out twice — once for each menu.
    This helps us stay organized and keep all 600+ holiday pies perfectly fresh for pickup week. 🥧

  • At this time, we’re not able to offer gluten-free, dairy-free, or sugar-free pies. Our kitchen is simply too small to guarantee no cross-contamination, and every pie we make is crafted with real sugar and butter.

  • Pick-up will be Wednesday, November 26th from 12–6pm.

    In years past we offered a separate pick -up window for pre-orders, but thanks to our streamlined system over the last two years, that’s no longer necessary!

  • Yes! However, confirmation from our team is required, as we’re not able to accommodate this on a large scale. When placing your order online, select the option “ YES - this is for the holiday” and then give the shop a call to confirm your early pick-up time.

  • Yes! However they are NOT available to pick up after November 21st.

    Place your order for the week of November 18th-21st and select “YES - this is for the holiday” while ordering and we’ll send them home frozen with thawing instructions so they’re ready for Thanksgiving.

    Whipped cream pies will come without topping (to stay fresh), but we’ll include easy instructions to make your own at home.

    Please note: these pies will NOT be available on our big Thanksgiving pickup day, November 26.

  • We will not be offering Create-Your-Own pies for the holiday.

  • We do not offer delivery, and are not connected with a local delivery service.

  • While you cannot pre-order slices to be picked up for the holiday, we will be selling slices on Thanksgiving Day for those who don’t need a whole pie for their celebration.

  • YES!! For the past two years we’ve opened our doors on Thanksgiving morning for all your last-minute pie needs—and we’re doing it again!

    We’ll be open from 10am–1pm on Thanksgiving Day, with everything available first come, first served. No pre-orders—just stop by to see what whole pies and slices are still up for grabs.

    A quick note: we’ll be serving slices, but since all our furniture will be cleared out to make room for prep, seating won’t be available that day. Grab your pie, take it home, and let the holiday feasting begin!

  • We are unable to offer any modifications (add whipped cream, cut into slices, add meringue, etc…) to our holiday pies.